- The CoVID-19 pandemic created an unprecedented global shock and killed hundreds of thousands
- Nations responded by closing their borders, implementing stringent lockdowns and saying the world is at war with a common invisible adversary
- Responses to the outbreak diverged in the different regions of the world
- Asian countries responded rapidly and effectively
- The US and UK responded slowly and ineffectively
- Observers suggested that the divergent responses to CoVID-19 signal a shift in power and influence from West to East
- National responses alone are insufficient to effectively deal with the coronavirus
- Only by embracing effective international cooperation will governments protect their citizens and safely exit the CoVID-19 crisis
National leaders have described the coronavirus CoVID-19 pandemic as “the enemy”. In attempts to protect their citizens, nations turned inwards and closed their borders, implemented stringent lockdown restrictions and suggested that the world is at war with a common adversary it cannot see. The speed and effectiveness of national responses to the new coronavirus crisis differed, but not even the wealthiest, most advanced nations were able to protect their citizens. The global coronavirus crisis made millions seriously ill, killed hundreds of thousands, destroyed industries, bankrupted thousands of companies, caused economies to nose-dive and threw societies into turmoil. Only by avoiding nationalist policies and embracing effective international cooperation will governments protect their citizens and safely exit the CoVID-19 crisis.
CoVID-19 has rapidly spread throughout the world with a scale and a severity not witnessed since the devastating Spanish Flu in 1918. So-called because Spain was neutral during WW1 and was one of the few countries where journalists were free to report on the outbreak. In an era before antibiotics and vaccines, the Spanish Flu claimed the lives of nearly 0.68m Americans, 0.25m Britons and between 50 to 100m people worldwide. Adjusting for population growth, that is equivalent to between 200 and 425m today.
At the time of writing - June 2020 - neither an adequate therapy nor a vaccine has been developed and CoVID-19 remains prevalent in populations throughout the world. Even with today’s scientific advances, infectious diseases are notoriously challenging to either treat or cure: an Ebola vaccine was more than two decades in the making; despite the first cases of the human immunodeficiency virus (HIV) presenting in 1983, we still do not have a therapeutic preventative vaccine for the disease; nor do we have a vaccine for severe acute respiratory syndrome (SARS), a killer coronavirus, which also originated in China and was unknown before its outbreak in 2002.
Notwithstanding, governments have lifted lockdown restrictions in order to get their economies working again. V, U, W and L are letters of the alphabet used to describe the shape of a recovery following the economic crisis caused by CoVID-19. Stringent lockdowns forced economies into unprecedented cold storage, and no one knows what shape a recovery will take since professional forecasters have never encountered anything like the sheer magnitude of the current economic crisis.
The Bank of England’s Monetary Policy Report published in May 2020, warned that the coronavirus has caused the worst economic crisis in 300 years. So, emerging from this is unlikely to be either straightforward or quick. National responses to the coronavirus outbreak were mixed. Although it is too soon to know the longer-term effects of the virus, China, Singapore and South Korea are among the countries that responded early and effectively, while the US and UK, together with other Western European countries, responded late and less effectively. As of June 1, China, with a population of 1.4bn, had 83,017 confirmed cases and 4,634 deaths; South Korea with a population of 52m, had 11,537 cases and 270 deaths, and Singapore with a population of 5.7m, had 34,884 confirmed cases and 23 deaths.
This Commentary describes the divergent national responses to the CoVID-19 pandemic; in particular that of China, Singapore, South Korea, the US and UK. China’s more effective response might have been because Beijing benefitted from the lessons it learned after the SARS epidemic in 2002. Governments also differed in their approaches to lifting restrictions. China’s approach was slower than that of the US and more determined to make some of the unexpected benefits thrown up by the crisis permanent. Some observers perceive such variances as a difference between liberal and illiberal nations. Others view the divergences as a shift in power and influence from West to East. We suggest that the divergent responses and outcomes are a product of the capacity and legal authority of different states and reveal different mindsets and competing views about solutions. We also contend that the devastation created by the pandemic will only be resolved with effective international cooperation. However, it is difficult to see this happening in the near term as the pandemic has become a theatre for a wider political disagreement between the US and China, in which other nation states are being forced to take sides.
China, Singapore and South Korea leveraged the collectivists mindset of their citizens, their centralised authority and digital infrastructures to quickly implement the gold standard “test-trace-and-isolate” strategy to reduce and control the virus. The reason for such prompt actions and the subsequent relatively low number of cases and deaths in these Asian countries is described by Byung-Chul Han, a South Korean-born German Professor of Philosophy at the Universität der Künste in Berlin. In an article published on May 22, in the Spanish newspaper El Pais, Han suggests that Asian nations won the battle against the CoVID-19 outbreak because their citizens, “have a collectivists mindset, which comes from their cultural tradition of Confucianism. Asians are less rebellious and more obedient than people in the West. They trust the state more. Daily life is much more organised, and Asians are strongly committed to digital surveillance. The epidemics in Asia are fought not only by virologists and epidemiologists but also by computer scientists and big data specialists”.
Given Iran’s response to CoVID-19 has been less effective, it seems reasonable to suggest that the Confucian mindset, rather than authoritarianism, appears to provide at least a short-term advantage. In early March, at the Shia Muslim Masumeh shrine in the holy city of Qom, pilgrims licked and kissed its gates. Qom experienced Iran’s first outbreak of the coronavirus and became the country's worst-hit city. Shortly afterwards the government closed all major Shia shrines across the Islamic republic and reopened them again in late May. As of June 1, Iran with a population of 81m, had confirmed 154,000 cases of CoVID-19 and 7,878 deaths.
Our clinical team treat a range of conditions relating to the muscular and skeletal systems, delivering effective care using the latest equipment and technology. If you require a Physiotherapist, Osteopath or Chiropractor in Leeds or Manchester, we are here to help.
Along with common complaints, such as neck and back pain, sports injuries, trapped nerves and postural issues, we also offer remedial treatment for conditions such as headaches, stress, insomnia, digestive issues, neurological conditions and more.
0113 345 5060
Mon - 10:00 AM - 07:00 PM
Tue - Thu: 07:30 AM – 07:30 PM
Fri: 07:30 AM - 06:00 PM
Sat: 09:00 AM - 01:00 PM
view this profile
Dr. Hari's Dental Clinic is the best Dental Clinic at Medavakkam, Chennai. We are experts in Sedation Dentistry, Dental Implants, Fillings & Root Canal Treatments, Oral & Maxillofacial Surgery - Bridges, Crowns & Dentures, Orthodontics - Dental Braces & Aligners, Advanced Gum Health & Gum Care, Cosmetic Dentistry, Special dental care for adults and kids, Teeth Alignment, Prosthodontic teeth replacement, Tooth trauma treatments, Laser Dentistry, Preventive Dentistry in Medavakkam, Chennai.
view this profile
JPRC is one of the best Neuro Spine Hospital in Jaipur, where problems like arthritis, spine and neck pain are treated with non-surgical treatment at the best price. Our team of experts and doctors will find the real cause of the disease and give you the right treatment and healthy life.
view this profile
The North Raleigh Pediatric Group is a team of leading physicians, nurses, and dedicated support staff that are here to help your child. We are committed to providing state-of-the-art, evidence-based pediatric care that is delivered in both a caring and efficient manner. We strive to maintain an environment that is both enjoyable, yet professional- enabling us to provide the highest level of performance for all of our patients. Each member of the North Raleigh Pediatric Group’s staff and doctors are dedicated to maintaining a respectful, team oriented environment. This level of dedication to our patients has continuously earned us a high level of patient satisfaction.
Contact Email ID:
Mon-Fri: 08:30 AM - 05:00 PM
Sat-Sun: 08:30 AM - 12:00 PM
view this profile
Nucleus IVF Treatment Centre in Pune has been providing quality IVF care with internationally comparable services and success rates. Our core strength lies in our ability to give to our patient's comprehensive ART and allied services from basic diagnostic work-up to advances fertility-enhancing endoscopic surgeries and In Vitro Fertilization techniques all under one roof.
Infertility is one of the biggest concerns in today’s world in both men and women it takes a toll on the dreams of parenthood. With the modern lifestyle that people, posses these days, infertility has turned out to be a common ailment. Nucleus Fertility Centres is one of the leading IVF clinics in Wakad and Pimple saudagar areas, Pune.
view this profile
"Boost Psychology is a practice located in South Edmonton. Boost offers therapy, provided by licensed Psychologists for a variety of issues. Our therapists are experienced in providing psychology services to individuals, couples, and families. Our mission is to create a healthy, warm, and inviting environment for all.
Kirsten is a Registered Psychologist who practices from a person-centred and cognitive behavioural perspective. She works with adolescents age 14 and up and adults. Kirsten is comfortable working with various issues including depression, anxiety, grief, life changes, relationship difficulties, PTSD and trauma. Kirsten uses Prolonged Exposure therapy for the treatment of PTSD and enjoys assisting people to regain function and return to healthier state post-trauma. She is especially passionate about working with stress and burnout and enjoys helping clients achieve balance in their lives."
view this profile
During these unprecedented challenging times caused by the coronavirus CoVID-19 pandemic, we trust that you all stay safe and well and let the spirit of Ramadan remain in your hearts and light up your souls from within.
To everyone working long and stressful hours on the frontline of healthcare; thank you for the sacrifices you’re making every day to help others in their moments of need. Your dedication, commitment and courage have our deepest gratitude and admiration.
Also, our heartfelt thanks go to all key workers who are unselfishly providing essential services, which are helping all of us through this coronavirus outbreak. Your resolution and mettle make a huge difference to our daily lives and we hold you in the highest esteem.
#coronavirus #CoVID-19 #frontlinehealthcareworkers #keyworkers #healthcare